Rachel watched Ryan’s hands shake as he held his coffee cup. “I just need to know where you are,” he said softly. “After what happened with Kate…” His voice trailed off, but Rachel knew the rest. How his ex had lied about working late, how she’d been meeting someone else for months while he stayed home, trusting and oblivious.
“It’s fine,” Rachel said, reaching across the table to steady his trembling hands. “I’ll text you when I get there and when I’m heading home.”
That was six months ago. Now, curled on her couch on a Friday night, Rachel stared at her phone. Three unread messages from her friends blinked on the screen – they were at their usual happy hour spot, wondering where she was. Her thumb hovered over the reply box, trying to find the right words. Ryan had been having a rough week at work, and when she’d mentioned happy hour plans, his face had fallen.
“You know I trust you,” he’d said. “It’s just… tonight’s hard. My anxiety’s through the roof, and you’re the only one who makes it better.”
So here she was, sending a quick “Sorry, can’t make it!” to the group chat. Ryan’s grateful smile when she’d offered to stay in had made her heart swell. After months of being breadcrumbed and ghosted by other men, Ryan’s emotional availability felt like finally finding solid ground. His double texts when she didn’t respond quickly weren’t clingy – they were proof she’d finally found someone who wasn’t afraid to show interest. She loved being his safe harbor, the one person who truly understood his fears.
But lately, a small voice had started whispering in the back of her mind. It spoke up when she caught herself scanning rooms for potential triggers before sharing stories about her day. It grew louder when she realized she couldn’t remember the last time she’d gone out without checking in every hour.
Was this just what being there for someone meant? Or was it something else?
Ryan appeared in the doorway with two mugs of tea, his face lighting up when he saw her. “You’re amazing,” he said, settling beside her. “I know staying in isn’t your favorite, but having you here…” He pulled her close, and she felt the familiar tension leaving his shoulders.
Rachel breathed in the comfort of the moment, the simple peace of being together. Yet somewhere underneath, that quiet voice kept asking its unanswered questions.
Love stories rarely come with clear labels, and the signs of toxic love can be subtle. Rachel’s friends see a boyfriend who needs constant reassurance – a red flag of toxic relationships to them. Rachel sees the tender moments – the way Ryan brings her tea without asking, how he listens intently to her work stories, the genuine way he thanks her for understanding him. The way his arms feel like home.
Some people would say it’s obviously toxic – the texts, the check-ins, the canceled plans. Others might call it devotion – standing by someone who’s hurting, choosing each other every day, working through the hard parts together. Maybe they’re both right. Or maybe they’re both missing something.
We all carry wounds from past relationships. Loving someone means understanding their scars. But the line between supporting someone’s healing and taking on their pain isn’t always clear. When does protecting their heart start to hurt yours? When does caring about their feelings turn into forgetting your own?
Rachel doesn’t know the answers. She just knows that in moments like these, she feels a mix of feelings: warmth at being the person Ryan trusts most in the world, and a nagging sensation that something isn’t quite right. Both feelings seem equally true, equally real.
When Two People’s Wounds Align
It’s a familiar dance, one playing out in living rooms and coffee shops everywhere. Partners carrying different wounds that fit together like puzzle pieces. Ryan needs constant reassurance because of past betrayal. Rachel gives it because somewhere along the way, she learned that being “understanding” meant putting her own needs last.
What makes it so hard to identify if a relationship is toxic or healthy is that they often start from a place of genuine care. The signs of controlling behavior emerge gradually. No one sets out to control or be controlled. Ryan isn’t trying to restrict Rachel’s world – in his mind, he’s just trying not to get blindsided again. And Rachel isn’t just accommodating Ryan’s fears – she’s following the script she learned long ago, where being loved meant never causing waves.
But relationships exist in patterns, not moments. For anyone wondering “is my relationship toxic or healthy?” it’s rarely about a single incident. One night staying in isn’t the issue. One skipped happy hour isn’t the problem. It’s the slow accumulation of adjustments – each one small, each one logical – that can gradually reshape someone’s world. When two people’s wounds align in ways that feel like fate but function like quicksand. His need for comfort meets her habit of saying yes. His anxiety meets her instinct to give up pieces of herself to keep someone else happy.
Recognizing Your Own Patterns
Recognizing patterns in our relationships is one challenge; knowing what to do when we spot them is another. The signs of toxic love aren’t always clear. How do we heal from old wounds without letting them run the show? How do we love someone and still get our own needs met?
These situations have no universal answers. Every relationship has its own complex history. But perhaps the first step in understanding toxic vs true love is seeing clearly how our pasts shape our present – and deciding if that’s the shape we want our futures to take. For Rachel, and for all of us, true love means finding the balance between caring deeply for someone and staying whole ourselves. In Rachel’s relationship, what began as understanding has slowly narrowed her world. Sometimes the bravest thing we can do is admit that what feels like destiny might actually be our old wounds talking. And sometimes real love means loving ourselves enough to make hard choices.
Ready for Change?
If this article resonated with you, there’s a reason. That voice inside you that questions whether you’re being understanding or making excuses? It’s trying to tell you something important.
I help women hear that voice – and more importantly, trust it. Because once you can tell the difference between real understanding and settling for less, everything about how you date and build relationships changes.
Ready to explore what that could mean for you? Click here to learn more.
We all know love isn’t always clear-cut. What do you think is the hardest part of figuring out whether a relationship is healthy or toxic? Share your thoughts below—your perspective might help others.
Over 40 and divorced? Here’s why smart men are fighting over women like you. Grab your FREE report now and discover your secret weapon in the dating game.
